Is a Low-FODMAP Diet Best for Digestive Disorders?
Do patients come to you with stubborn digestive disorders? When basic dietary changes aren’t enough, removing certain types of carbohydrates called FODMAPs from the diet may be helpful. Read on to learn the evidence for a low-FODMAP diet, how to implement it, and why it should only be used as a short-term therapeutic strategy.
Digestive disorders are perhaps the number one complaint I see clinically. They range from irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) to gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) and everything in between. In many cases, adopting an anti-inflammatory, nutrient-dense Paleo diet that supports gut health leads to complete resolution of digestive disorders. In other cases, a more drastic intervention may be necessary. For example, I recently wrote about the Paleo autoimmune protocol (AIP) and its success for patients with IBD.
Another potential intervention is a low-FODMAP diet. FODMAP stands for fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols. In a patient with healthy gut function, many of these carbohydrates are beneficial, acting as prebiotics that stimulate the proliferation of healthy gut microbes. In patients with digestive disorders, however, they can exacerbate symptoms like gas, bloating, diarrhea, gut pain, and even GERD.
In this article, I’ll discuss the evidence for a low-FODMAP diet, how to implement it, and the long-term consequences of a low-FODMAP approach.
Should you stay on a low-FODMAP diet forever?
Efficacy of Low-FODMAP for Symptom Reduction
Low-FODMAP diets have been studied extensively for “functional gut disorders” like IBS. Consuming FODMAPs does not actually cause the gut disorder; rather, it exacerbates symptoms because it feeds the microbes in the small intestine. Thus, reducing FODMAPs may provide significant relief by reducing small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) (1). About 84 percent of patients with IBS have a positive lactulose breath test for SIBO (2).
Unfortunately, no studies to date have looked at the effect of a low-FODMAP diet on long-term SIBO outcomes. Still, the low-FODMAP diet can provide effective short-term relief. One study found that low-FODMAP diets reduced symptom severity in 76 percent of patients with IBS compared to a 54 percent reduction in a group receiving standard diet advice. Bloating, flatulence, and abdominal pain were all reduced on the low-FODMAP diet (3). Clinically, I’ve also found low-FODMAP diets to be useful in patients with Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis, and diverticulosis.
What Foods Have FODMAPs?
Now that we’ve established why low-FODMAP is an appropriate choice for symptom relief, let’s look at what foods contain FODMAPs:
Excess fructose: Honey, apple, mango, pear, watermelon, high-fructose corn syrup, agave syrup, dried fruit, fruit juice
Fructans: Artichokes (globe), artichokes (Jerusalem), asparagus, beetroot, broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, eggplant, fennel, okra, chicory, dandelion leaves, garlic (in large amounts), leek, onion (brown, white, Spanish, onion powder), radicchio, lettuce, spring onion (white part), wheat, rye, pistachio, inulin, fructo-oligosaccharides.
Lactose: Milk, ice cream, custard, dairy desserts, condensed and evaporated milk, milk powder, yogurt, soft unripened cheeses (such as ricotta, cottage, cream, and mascarpone cheese).
Galactans: Legumes (such as baked beans, kidney beans, soybeans, lentils, chickpeas).
Polyols: Apple, apricot, avocado, blackberry, cherry, longan, lychee, nectarine, pear, plum, prune, mushroom, sorbitol, mannitol, xylitol, maltitol, and isomalt.
I usually recommend removing all FODMAPs from the patient’s diet for a period of 30 days.
This may seem like a lot, but in my clinical experience, most patients do not have the same reaction to each class of FODMAPs listed above. For example, some people seem to have no trouble with lactose but do very poorly with excess fructose. Others may tolerate polyols but not fructans. After the initial 30-day period, I recommend reintroducing FODMAPs one category at a time to see which are well tolerated. For instance, once the patient knows how fructans affect her, then you could recommend reintroducing the foods with excess fructose, and so forth.
It’s also rarely necessary to completely eradicate FODMAPs from the diet. FODMAP intolerance is not like gluten or casein intolerance. In those cases, the immune system reacts—regardless of how much of that food you eat. With FODMAP intolerance, it’s more of a threshold response. If a person is eating a lot of FODMAPs daily, the threshold for tolerating FODMAPs will be quite low. However, if the overall intake of FODMAPs is low, the patient may be able to tolerate small amounts without much problem. This can make things a little easier when people are eating out, traveling, or are in an environment where they don’t have as much control over their food choices.
The Dangers of Long-Term Low-FODMAP
Another reason to reintroduce at least some FODMAPs back into the diet is their function as prebiotics. At least two studies have shown that long-term low-FODMAP diets alter the colonic environment and reduce the levels of beneficial bacteria in the colon (4, 5).
Some of my patients have found that a few months on a low-FODMAP diet was sufficient to reduce their sensitivity to FODMAPs upon reintroduction. If you reintroduce FODMAPs and the patient still has symptoms, consider testing the patient for SIBO. After SIBO treatment, patients may be able to tolerate some or all FODMAPs again.
Digestive disorders are complex, multifactorial conditions. However, I’ve seen many patients achieve complete resolution with the proper diet, lifestyle, and supplemental support. Here’s a quick summary of my recommendations:
- Start patients with a 30-day Paleo reset. Many patients have digestive disorders that resolve simply from removing inflammatory foods from their diet.
- Try a low-FODMAP diet for 30 days. This can provide significant symptom relief and may reduce proliferation of bacteria in the small intestine.
- After 30 to 60 days, reintroduce FODMAPs by category. Staying on a low-FODMAP diet long term can negatively impact beneficial microbes that rely on fermentable carbohydrates.
- Test and treat SIBO. Most patients find that their symptoms are only managed by a low-FODMAP diet; they do not disappear completely. Addressing SIBO using antimicrobials should improve FODMAP intolerance over time in those with digestive abnormalities. Be sure that the patient is not on a low-FODMAP diet during SIBO treatment though!
Frequently Asked Questions:
The most common time period for low FODMAP diet is 30-60 days before you start to slowly reintroduce FODMAP foods. However, this is not a hard and fast rule as most of the time the length of the diet will depend on each patient’s individual case and symptoms.
As with any diets the focus should be on prepping and sticking to your plan. Come up with a list of foods allowed on the elimination diet and start removing the high FODMAP foods to get to a list that will suit your needs.
I first came across your information when I was at my wits end on dealing with IBS in 2012. At that point my body was not absorbing any of the food I was eating. I started learning about FODMAP foods and then started learning that there were days I could tolerate some of the foods and other days were I could not. I then started to realize I needed to look at the combination of foods I was eating and the amounts. I use an App called Monash University Low FODMAP Diet Guide as it gives you an idea of the quantities that you may or may not be able to tolerate. Knowing then what foods my body couldn’t tolerate well together (like Sweet potatoes and avocado – Boohoo!) I was then able to become symptom free. It is nice to finally see the differentiation mentioned/confirmed in how FODMAP is different than a gluten intolerance. I always explained to people that I have to look at the combination and amounts of the food I eat to achieve my personal gut balance. This was life changing in that going to the bathroom was no longer 6-8 times a day but 1 normal day if you get my drift. Doctors just wanted to medicate me which would just make things feel worse. I am glad that I was able to find a natural way to deal with my IBS. Many thanks to you and the research you are doing! You are truly impacting people’s lives in a very positive way!
I live near Frankfurt, Germany and was wondering if you could recommend a practitioner near here.
Great article, and really helpful. I have one question-
What is the reason for – “Be sure that the patient is not on a low-FODMAP diet during SIBO treatment though!”?
You want to keep the bacterial overgrowth from going dormant (essentially into hiding) from lack of nutrients. That way the antibiotics/herbals can go to work on them more effectively.
wondering if there are responses to the questions
Thank you for sharing about low FODMAP. I always very eager to know more about low fodmap especially Low FODMAP Recipes. I have found Some Instant Low Fodmap Recipes Here:
If You’re looking for low fodmap recipes then you can visit the blog also. It contains more Low FODMAP Recipes.