Goitrogenic Foods and Thyroid Health
Warnings about goitrogenic foods are popping up on alternative and conventional healthcare sites alike. The truth is, goitrogens can be a problem, especially for patients with thyroid problems. Read on to learn what foods are goitrogenic, how food can be prepared to limit them, and which patients should be extra concerned about goitrogens.
The Thyroid Controls Metabolism
The small, butterfly-shaped thyroid gland has big responsibilities. The thyroid and its hormones control metabolism throughout the body, affecting the brain, GI tract, cardiovascular system, lipid and cholesterol metabolism, hormone synthesis, gallbladder and liver function, and more.
Unfortunately, 20 million Americans suffer from some form of thyroid disease, and 60 percent of those who have it may not even be aware. One in eight women will develop a thyroid disorder in her lifetime. If something disrupts thyroid function, the health consequences can be widespread.
Goitrogenic Substances Interfere with Iodine Uptake in the Thyroid
The term “goitrogenic” means something that causes “goiter,” or swelling of the thyroid gland. Goitrogens accomplish this by interfering with iodine uptake in the thyroid gland. When not enough iodine is available, the thyroid cannot produce sufficient levels of thyroid hormones T4 and T3. The hypothalamus senses low T4 and releases TSH-releasing hormone, which triggers the pituitary gland to produce TSH. The thyroid gland responds to TSH by making more hormones. If it can’t keep up with demand, it grows bigger trying.
Goitrogens, found in many vegetables, can be problematic for patients with thyroid disorders.
Goitrins, thiocyanates, and nitriles are all goitrogenic chemicals derived from natural plant pesticides called glucosinolates. During digestion, an enzyme breaks down glucosinolates into both goitrogenic and non-goitrogenic byproducts (1).
Foods that have been identified as goitrogenic include cruciferous vegetables such as bok choy, broccoli, brussels sprouts, cabbage, canola, cauliflower, Chinese cabbage, coy sum, collard greens, horseradish, kai-lan, kale, kohlrabi, mizuna, mustard greens, radishes, rapeseed, rapini, rutabagas, and turnips. The Rosaceae family of fruits, which includes almonds, apricots, cherries, peaches, pears, plums, raspberries, and strawberries, is also goitrogenic. Other examples are bamboo shoots, millet, soy, spinach, sweet potato, tapioca, and yuca (cassava or manioc).
Many chemicals from the environment and medications are also classified as goitrogenic:
- Amiodarone (medication for irregular heart beat)
- Bromides (from pesticides, plastic, brominated vegetable oils, medications)
- Dioxins (toxic industrial byproducts)
- Heavy metals
- Lithium and benzodiazepines (depression and anxiety drugs)
- Oxazolidines (from paint)
- Perchlorates (from jet fuel, water)
- Thiocyanate (in cigarettes)
At relatively low concentrations, goitrogens decrease the uptake of iodine by the thyroid gland. This effect can often be offset by supplementing with iodine. However, exposure to large amounts of goitrogens impairs the incorporation of iodine into thyroid hormone itself, which means that the thyroid gland can’t properly utilize the iodine. In this case, no amount of supplemental iodine would be able to overcome a large intake of goitrogenic substances.
Kale and Broccoli: Health Foods or Thyroid Toxins?
Goitrogens are not an outright death sentence for kale and broccoli. Fruit and vegetable consumption in general lowers the risk of chronic diseases (2). Before you stop recommending antioxidant-rich fruits and vegetables to your patients, keep reading. The goitrogen content of foods varies widely and can be modified.
Crucifers are the biggest goitrogenic offenders, with certain varieties of kale, collard greens, and brussels sprouts at the top of the list. Others have significantly lower goitrogen levels. For example, the progoitrin (one of the harmful downstream products of glucosinolates) content per dry weight of Russian kale is approximately 150 times higher than that of Chinese cabbage (1).
Fortunately, cooking lowers the goitrogenic content of foods. Steaming crucifers until fully cooked reduces goitrogens by two-thirds. Boiling crucifers for 30 minutes destroys 90 percent of the goitrogens by stimulating the production of myrosinase, an enzyme that helps deactivate goitrogenic glucosinolates (3).
On the flip side, when green vegetables are boiled and the water is discarded, some beneficial nutrients are lost as well. About 45 percent of the vitamin C, 20 percent of the thiamin, and 40 percent of the folate are lost (4). Minerals (calcium, iron, etc.), vitamin B12, vitamin A, and others are very well retained. Steaming versus boiling will retain more nutrients. Although some nutrients leach out, cooking goitrogenic foods is generally beneficial.
In contrast to cooking, fermenting increases the goitrogen content of cabbage, but it simultaneously decreases the level of nitriles (5). Because nitriles are more harmful than goitrogens, the overall effect of fermentation is probably positive.
In a given week, if a patient is enjoying a couple of sides of steamed broccoli, a few servings of sauerkraut, and several small salads containing spinach and kale, that shouldn’t be a problem. On the other hand, if a patient is downing green smoothies every day, each with two or more cups of raw kale or spinach, then I would be worried about how that’s affecting thyroid function.
Bottom line: encourage your patients to steam or boil goitrogenic foods and not to consume them in excess.
Patients Who Are Susceptible to Goitrogenic Foods
Certain groups of patients need to take special considerations when it comes to goitrogenic foods:
Patients at Risk for Iodine Deficiency
As stated earlier, goitrogens reduce the uptake of iodine in the thyroid. If someone is already iodine-deficient, then goitrogens are more likely to cause issues. Despite iodized salt supplementation programs, iodine deficiency is on the rise. In Europe, it’s estimated that up to 44 percent of the population maybe be iodine-deficient (6).
The best food sources of iodine come from the sea: seaweeds, cod, shrimp, and tuna. Eggs and iodized salt are also options. Have your patients start with lower-iodine-containing foods and work their way up to higher levels. Simultaneously, ensure proper selenium intake. Selenium is best obtained from foods such as Brazil nuts, cremini mushrooms, cod, shrimp, tuna, halibut, salmon, scallops, chicken, eggs, shiitake mushrooms, lamb, and turkey.
Patients with Thyroid Problems
For patients already experiencing thyroid problems, especially hypothyroidism, goitrogens will exacerbate the condition (1). These patients should be limiting their cruciferous vegetables to one cooked serving per day. And take it easy on the green smoothies!
If you suspect a patient has thyroid issues, make sure you run a full thyroid blood work panel, which should include the standard TSH and T4, but also T3, free T3, free T4, and thyroid antibodies.
Pregnant and Nursing Women
Pregnant and nursing women require 50 percent more iodine than the average adult, making them extra susceptible to iodine deficiency (7, 8, 9). Goitrogens can inhibit the transfer of iodine into a mother’s breast milk. In a study of Boston mothers, 47 percent of breast milk samples did not have sufficient levels of iodine (10). I recommend only three to five servings per week of cooked cruciferous vegetables and other highly goitrogenic foods for these patients.
Further Dietary Considerations for Thyroid Health
Patients with thyroid disorders may also want to consider other dietary choices.
Oxalates protect plants from being eaten by critters and are found in most plants, nuts, and seeds. Spinach, okra, sweet potato, elderberry, figs, leeks, buckwheat, celery, other leafy greens, and dandelions are some sources. For frame of reference, ingesting 250 mg of oxalates is considered high, and one cup of raw spinach contains a whopping 656 mg (11).
Oxalic acid binds minerals like calcium and potassium, making them insoluble and less bioavailable (12). Oxalate salts increase the risk of kidney stones, especially in patients with gut dysbiosis. Gut bacteria are responsible for breaking down oxalates, but when the microbiota are compromised, oxalates can enter the blood, turn into crystals, and get stored in tissues like the kidney. In one study, 65 percent of kidney stones contained calcium oxalate (13). Unfortunately, cooking doesn’t decrease the oxalate content much.
Foods that May Trigger an Immune Response
For patients with an autoimmune thyroid disorder, eggs, nightshades, and dairy products are common offenders.
Industrial Seed Oils
Chronic inflammation can worsen thyroid disorders. The high content of omega-6 fatty acids in industrial seed oils drives inflammation.
Very-Low-Carb or Low-Protein Diets
Carbs and proteins both promote the release of insulin, which is required to convert T4 to T3. Have your patients aim their macros to at least 20 percent carbs and 10 percent protein. The increasingly popular keto diet may not be appropriate.
Other Strategies to Improve Thyroid Function
I deal with thyroid disorders often in my practice, and they can be very complex conditions. For more information, check out my articles about the thyroid’s connection with cardiovascular disease, the gut microbiome, blood sugar, and more. Beyond limiting goitrogenic foods, other strategies I recommend to improve thyroid function include the following:
- Manage stress – Stress impairs thyroid function (14, 15)
- Heal the gut – Gut bacteria assist in converting T4 to T3 (16)
- Monitor vitamin D status – Vitamin D deficiency is associated with numerous autoimmune diseases
- Avoid bromide and other iodine toxins
- Minimize exposure to toxins
There is no vitamin A in any plant food on the planet.
Not that its needed anyway. Ppl not converting b-carotine to v-a is a scam.
Looks like kale has some.
Wondering your thoughts on how ROASTING crucifers affects goitrogens? MANY opt for this method of cooking year round, and grilling is in full swing this time of year! #biomeonboardawareness
This was very helpful, thank you! I am hypothyroid and I have mast cell activation syndrome/mastocytosis (diagnosed by a NYC immunologist). I was thinking that salicylates in the greens I was eating were contributing to my debilitating chronic fatigue, but now that this goitrogen information has come to light, perhaps it’s the goitrogenic foods that are contributing to the problem.
I must follow a low histamine diet (which is really hard to do!) because it keeps the overt mast cell symptoms at bay as long as external things like chemicals, mold, heat, pollen, etc do not cause mast cell degranulation, but the brain fog and fatigue continue to debilitate me (I am on disability becasue of my illness).
I was about to do a low-salicylate elimination diet in order to see if this chemical was an issue and contributing to the fatigue because very often salicylate intolerance accompanies histamine intolerance and share the same symptoms (like fatigue and fog). Also, fatigue and fog are hypothyroid symptoms as well. This 4-week salicylate elimination diet, however, relies heavily upon goitrogens since there are no amines, salicylates or amines included in it. Perhaps I should rethink this…
Do you think that lowering or doing a goitrogen detox might help with the chronic fatigue and brain fog? Even though my thyroid numbers are now good (good T3), I still have thyroid symptoms, like the fog and fatigue, and hair loss, dry skin and more.
It’s a crazy conundrum because my symptoms overlap with several conditions, I do not know what condition is causing what issue. I do know that I have not tried a low-sal or low-goitrogen diet so perhaps one or the other could help. After reading this article, I am leaning towards goitrogens.
Any thoughts? I am very sick and tired of being sick and tired. Thank you.
correction… This 4-week salicylate elimination diet, however, relies heavily upon goitrogens since there are no amines, salicylates or glutamines included in it.
In addition to my previous lengthy comment and questions, I have more questions.
If we are taking thyroid meds (I am taking NP natural desiccated) and our numbers are all good, including free T3 in the upper 20 percentile of the normal range, will goitrogenic foods still be a problem to those of us with hypothyroidism?
Should we eat no more than Chris’ recommended 1 cooked serving of goitrogenic food daily?
If our numbers are good due to our meds, does goitrogenic intake matter? Or does the ingestion of goitrogens tax our thyroid despite taking the meds?
Does ingesting goitrogens weaken the effect of thyroid meds?
Does ingesting goitrogens exacerbate our hypothyroid symptoms (like fatigue and brain fog and hair loss) despite having consistently good lab work?
I dry extra kale, spinach and other greens in the sun or on low heat in a dehydrator for addition to smoothies in the winter. Does this reduce the goitrogenic effect of these foods as steaming does?
Are the goitrogenic effects of sprouts and micro greens of the cruciferous vegetables higher, lower, or the same?
Yes I am working with a person with under active thyroid at the moment and have advised her to limit consumption of goitrogenic foods but not eliminate them and to make sure they’re steamed / cooked. I’ve advised on may other things and so far she’s feeling amazing!
If we’re supposed to eat 4-6 fruits and veges a day, yet oxalates can cause kidney stones et al even when cooked, and goitrogens seem to be in everything and cause thyroid disease, What the hell are we supposed to eat????